PSYCH OpenIR  > 社会与工程心理学研究室
职业召唤与职业倦怠:组织自尊、生命意义的中介与组态效应
其他题名The mediating role and configuration effects of organizationbased self-esteem and life meaning between career calling and job burnout
王文
导师陈毅文
2023-12
摘要2022 年,“内卷”、“躺平”二词在互联网掀起了一波又一波讨论热潮,引发了大量关注与思考。内卷持续发酵的压力让诸多不堪重负的职场人放弃“内卷”, 选择“躺平”。“躺平”是一种消极的职业状态,不担当、不作为等现象让组织与组织管理者深感棘手。鉴于此,学界将目光从过去卓有成效但逐渐式微的物质激励转向精神激励,试图从“信仰”与“价值”层面探求解决之道,职业召唤(又 称“职业使命感”)在这一背景下进入学者视野,成为组织行为领域的研究热点。 职业召唤的研究正在兴起,但存在诸多分歧。近期,越来越多的研究开始关注职业召唤的双刃剑效应。目前,国内对职业召唤与心理健康的关系关注尚不够,对于职业召唤如何影响职业倦怠的内部机制存在进一步探究的空间,尤其在中国制造业职场环境中,职业召唤量表的适用性、影响机制都需要更丰富的实证研究予以证实,给予组织及组织管理者更多的实践启发。本研究基于中国制造业职场环境下分析职业召唤对职业倦怠的影响与内部心理机制,探讨组织自尊、生命意义在职业召唤与职业倦怠间的中介效应,并运用 fsQCA 模糊集比较分析的定性研究方法针对职业召唤、组织自尊、生命意义对职业倦怠的组态效应进行了探究, 将方差的定量分析方法与模糊集定性研究方法相结合,通过研究一与研究二得出了更丰富的研究结论。 研究一预实验在方便样本中展开,收集到 125 份有效问卷,量表和假设验证 结果与正式研究一致。正式研究分三个时间点对某制造业 736 名员工发起电子问 卷调查,采用本土化 DOBROW 职业召唤量表、STEGER 生命意义量表、PIERCE 组织自尊量表、MASLACH 职业倦怠量表进行三阶段追踪数据调查,分析职业召 唤影响职业倦怠的路径与机制。通过对三轮数据的 ID 匹配,获得有效样本 148人。结果发现,在控制了一系列人口学变量后,职业召唤与组织自尊、生命存在意义、生命寻求意义均呈正相关(β=0.49、0.48、0.21,均 P<0.05),与职业倦怠呈负相关(β=-0.26,P<0.01);组织自尊、生命存在意义与职业倦怠呈负相关(β=-0.21、-0.30,均 P<0.05),且组织自尊、生命存在意义在职业召唤与职 业倦怠间起部分中介作用,中介效应占总效应的46.6%,生命寻求意义的作用不显著。研究一结论:职业召唤正向预测组织自尊、生命存在意义,负向预测职业倦怠,生命存在意义、组织自尊在职业召唤与职业倦怠间起部分中介作用。研究假设经预实验与正式研究验证具有一致性。 研究一预实验在方便样本中展开,收集到 125 份有效问卷,量表和假设验证 结果与正式研究一致。正式研究分三个时间点对某制造业 736 名员工发起电子问 卷调查,采用本土化 DOBROW 职业召唤量表、STEGER 生命意义量表、PIERCE组织自尊量表、MASLACH 职业倦怠量表进行三阶段追踪数据调查,分析职业召 唤影响职业倦怠的路径与机制。通过对三轮数据的 ID 匹配,获得有效样本 148人。结果发现,在控制了一系列人口学变量后,职业召唤与组织自尊、生命存在 意义、生命寻求意义均呈正相关(β=0.49、0.48、0.21,均 P<0.05),与职业倦怠呈负相关(β=-0.26,P<0.01);组织自尊、生命存在意义与职业倦怠呈负相关(β=-0.21、-0.30,均 P<0.05),且组织自尊、生命存在意义在职业召唤与职业倦怠间起部分中介作用,中介效应占总效应的 46.6%,生命寻求意义的作用不显著。研究一结论:职业召唤正向预测组织自尊、生命存在意义,负向预测职业倦怠,生命存在意义、组织自尊在职业召唤与职业倦怠间起部分中介作用。研究假设经预实验与正式研究验证具有一致性。 为了进一步探究职业召唤影响路径的多样性,研究二运用 fsQCA 的分析方 法,在正式研究的企业中抽取样本,展开了组态特性的探索。研究二在研究一的一年后展开,一次性收集 229 份有效样本数据。分析结果显示,变量间不同水平的组合关系在样本中呈现了较强的集中性,高水平职业倦怠与低水平职业倦怠分别有典型的两个组态。低水平职业倦怠:第一,无论生命存在意义和组织自尊的水平高低,高水平的职业召唤和高水平的生命寻求意义会带来低职业倦怠; 第二, 无论生命意义感是高还是低, 高职业召唤水平作为边缘条件与高水平的组织自尊作为核心条件一起会带来低职业倦怠。高水平职业倦怠: 第一,无论生命存在意义的水平高低,低水平的职业召唤、生命寻求意义与组织自尊作为并行的三个核心条件会导致高职业倦怠; 第二, 无论职业召唤和生命寻求意义的水平是高还是低, 低水平的生命存在意义和组织自尊作为共同的核心条件会导致高职业倦怠。结果显示,职业召唤、生命存在意义、生命寻求意义、组织自尊对职业倦怠的影响存在协同效应,对研究一的研究结果形成了有益补充。 本研究启示职业召唤和生命意义、组织自尊的激发、维持对个体职业倦怠的降低具有重要价值。
其他摘要In 2022, the two high-frequency words "internal volume" and "lying flat" have set off waves of discussion on the Internet, causing a lot of attention and thinking. The pressure of continuous fermentation of the inner volume makes many overwhelmed workers give up the "inner volume" and choose to "lie flat". "Lying flat" is manifested as a negative occupational state, and the phenomenon of non-responsibility and inaction makes the organization and the organization manager deeply troublesome. In view of this, the academic community has turned its attention from the past effective but gradually declining material motivation level to the spiritual motivation level, trying to explore the unique solution of "belief" and "value" level. Career calling(also known as "career mission") has entered the field of scholars' vision and become a research hotspot in the field of organizational behavior. The research of career calling is emerging, but there are many differences. Recently, more and more studies have begun to focus on the negative effects and double-edged sword effects of career calling. At present, China has not paid enough attention to the relationship between career calling and mental health, and there is room for further exploration on how career calling affects the internal mechanism of job burnout. Especially in the workplace environment of China's manufacturing industry, the applicability and influence mechanism of career calling scale need to be confirmed by more empirical studies, which will give more practical inspiration to organizations and organization managers. Based on the workplace environment of China's manufacturing industry, this study analyzes the influence and internal psychological mechanism of career calling on job burnout, explores the mediating effect of organizational self-esteem and meaning of life between career calling and job burnout, and uses the qualitative research method of fsQCA fuzzy set comparative analysis to explore the organizational impact of career calling, organizational self-esteem and meaning of life on job burnout. By combining the quantitative analysis method of variance with the qualitative research method of fuzzy sets, more abundant research conclusions are obtained. The pre-experiment was conducted in a convenient sample, and 125 valid questionnaires were collected. The results of scale and hypothesis testing were consistent with those of the formal study. The formal study launched an electronic questionnaire survey on 736 employees in a manufacturing industry at three time points, and conducted a three-stage tracking data survey with the local DOBROW Career calling Scale, STEGER Meaning of Life Scale, PIERCE Organizational self-esteem Scale and MASLACH Burnout Scale, to analyze the path and mechanism of career calling's impact on job burnout. Through ID matching of three rounds of data, 148 valid samples were obtained. The results showed that after controlling for a series of demographic variables, career calling was positively correlated with organizational self-esteem, the presence for life meaning, the search for life meaning (β=0.49, 0.48, 0.21, all P < 0.05), and negatively correlated with job burnout (β=-0.26, P < 0.01). Organizational self-esteem and the presence for life meaning were negatively correlated with job burnout (β=-0.21, -0.30, both P < 0.05). Organizational self-esteem and the presence for life meaning played a partial mediating role between job calling and job burnout, and the mediating effect accounted for 46.6% of the total effect, while the effect of the search for life meaning was not significant. According to the first study, career calling is positively correlated with organizational self-esteem and the presence for life meaning, and negatively correlated with job burnout. The presence for life meaning significance and organizational selfesteem play a partial mediating role between career calling and job burnout. The results of the study are consistent with those of the preliminary experiment and the formal study. In order to further explore the diversity of career calling influence paths, Study 2 uses the analysis method of fsQCA to extract samples from formally studied enterprises and explore the configuration characteristics. Study 2 was conducted one year after Study 1 and collected 229 valid sample data at one time. The analysis results show that the combination relationship between variables at different levels presents a strong concentration in the sample, and high level job burnout and low level job burnout have two typical configurations respectively. Low level of job burnout: First, regardless of the level of the presence for life meaning and organizational self-esteem, high level of job calling and high level of the search for life meaning will bring low job burnout; Second, regardless of whether the presence for life meaning is high or low, a high level of career calling as a marginal condition and a high level of organizational self-esteem as a core condition will bring about low job burnout. High level of job burnout: First, regardless of the level of the presence for life meaning, low level of job calling, the search for life meaning and organizational self-esteem as three core conditions will lead to high level of job burnout; Second, regardless of whether the level of career calling and the search for life meaning is high or low, low level of the presence for life meaning and organizational self-esteem as common core conditions will lead to high job burnout. The results show that career calling, life meaning, the search for life meaning and organizational self-esteem have synergistic effects on job burnout, which is a richer complement to the research results of study 1. This study reveals that the stimulation and maintenance of career calling、meaning of life, organizational self-esteem are of great value to the reduction of individual job burnout.
关键词职业召唤 职业倦怠 组织自尊 生命意义
学位类型硕士
语种中文
学位名称理学硕士
学位专业应用心理学
学位授予单位中国科学院大学
学位授予地点中国科学院心理研究所
文献类型学位论文
条目标识符https://ir.psych.ac.cn/handle/311026/47380
专题社会与工程心理学研究室
推荐引用方式
GB/T 7714
王文. 职业召唤与职业倦怠:组织自尊、生命意义的中介与组态效应[D]. 中国科学院心理研究所. 中国科学院大学,2023.
条目包含的文件
文件名称/大小 文献类型 版本类型 开放类型 使用许可
王文-同等学力论文.pdf(1698KB)学位论文 开放获取CC BY-NC-SA请求全文
个性服务
推荐该条目
保存到收藏夹
查看访问统计
导出为Endnote文件
谷歌学术
谷歌学术中相似的文章
[王文]的文章
百度学术
百度学术中相似的文章
[王文]的文章
必应学术
必应学术中相似的文章
[王文]的文章
相关权益政策
暂无数据
收藏/分享
所有评论 (0)
暂无评论
 

除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。