PSYCH OpenIR  > 社会与工程心理学研究室
移动警务终端装备用户体验模型研究:以执法记录仪为例
其他题名A study on user experience model of mobile police terminal equipment: body-worn cameras as an example
尚炎
导师张警吁
2023-12
摘要随着通信、物联网技术的发展,中国移动智能终端的使用全面增长,移动应用进一步赋能社会民生,公安行业移动警务终端装备也正经历新的技术升级和发展。科技发展带来更多功能的增加,而如何平衡不断增加的功能和良好的用户体验的关系,成为行业终端产品设计新的挑战。为了更好的应对行业的挑战,本研究旨在通过质性研究和定量研究等系统性方法,建立移动警务终端装备的用户体验模型。本研究包括三部分:交通警察关键场景研究(研究一)、执法记录仪用户体验模型初步建立(研究二)、执法记录仪用户体验模型验证(研究三)。 研究一旨在分析交警业务场景,并围绕关键业务场景探讨移动终端装备的需求。本研究采取了层次任务分析的方法,通过文献分析、用户访谈和实地观察等手段收集信息,提取了主要任务场景五个,包括路面交通疏导、查缉酒驾醉驾、违章车辆拦截、事故快速处置、严重事故处置,并分析了各个任务场景中使用移动终端的关键要点难点,及其对现有终端装备的对应需求。本研究发现,执法记录仪是目前交警在各个警务活动中需求程度较高,存在多种类型体验问题并且能一定程度代表警务终端中警务通和对讲机的体验特征的产品类别。因此,我们选择其作为警务终端装备的典型产品,开展进一步用户体验模型建立和验证研究。 研究二旨在初步建立执法记录仪的用户体验模型。基于文献分析和研究一开展的用户调查记录分析,我们首先建立了包含有 24 个条目的执法记录仪用户体验问卷,并收集了197 名有执法记录仪使用经验的警察的问卷回答结果。通过探索性因素分析发现“可用性、易用性”二因子能够较好地解释数据,内部一致性系数较高,并均与用户整体满意度、推荐意愿和感知使用收益有显著性相关。并且分析表明,在所有用户体验特征的条目,电池续航力、影像清晰度、夜间清晰度、归档简易性、便携性是用户觉得执法记录仪最重要的五个特征。 研究三采集新一批样本182 名警察对执法记录仪用户体验模型进行了验证。通过验证性因子分析表明,“有用性、易用性”二因素模型具有较高的模型拟合优度,说明该模型具有良好的结构效度。进一步分析表明二个因子均同用户整体满意度、推荐意愿和感知使用收益显著性相关。第二批用户认为最重要的体验特征是电池续航力、影像清晰度、夜间清晰度、便携性、归档简易性。 本研究以执法记录仪为例,构建了移动警务终端装备的用户体验模型,以技术接受度模型(TAM)为理论依据,并将其理论扩展到通过可用性维度解释和预测用户对产品体验的满意程度,补充了警用装备领域用户体验研究缺乏实证研究的用户体验模型的情况。本研究所构建的用户体验模型,可以用来构建移动警务终端装备的可用性通用标准,指导产品改进和创新设计的方向,提高行业终端装备的用户体验水平,最终达到提升执法效能的目的,为促进和谐社会的建立提供支持。未来的研究可以在此模型的基础上,增加多警种的业务场景研究,并在执法记录仪以外的终端装备上进行验证,不断完善模型。
其他摘要The development of science and technology has brought about the increase of more functions, and how to balance the relationship between increasing functions and good user experience has become a new challenge for the design of terminal products in the industry. To better cope with this challenge in the industry, this study aims to establish a user experience model of mobile police terminal equipment through systematic methods such as qualitative research and quantitative research. This study includes three parts: traffic police key scene research (Study 1), law enforcement recorder user experience model preliminary establishment (Study 2), and law enforcement recorder user experience model verification (Study 3). The Study 1 aims to analyze traffic police business scenarios and discuss the need for mobile terminal equipment around key business scenarios. This study adopts the method of hierarchical task analysis, collects information utilizing literature analysis, user interviews and field observation, and extracts five main task scenarios, including road traffic facilitation, detection and suppression of drunk driving, illegal vehicle interception, quick accident handling, and serious accident handling, and analyzes the key points and difficulties of using mobile terminals in each task scenario. And corresponding requirements for existing terminal equipment. This study finds that the law enforcement recorder is a product category that the traffic police has a high demand in various police activities, has a variety of types of experience problems, and can represent the experience characteristics of police radios and police terminals to a certain extent. Therefore, we choose it as a typical product of police terminal equipment to carry out further research on the establishment and verification of the user experience model. The second Study aims to establish the user experience model of law enforcement recorders. Based on literature analysis and interview record analysis conducted in Study 1, we first established a 24-item user experience questionnaire for law enforcement recorders, and collected the results of 197 police officers with experience in using law enforcement recorders. Through exploratory factor analysis, it is found that the two factors of "usability and ease of use" can explain the data better, and the internal consistency coefficient is high, and they are significantly correlated with the overall satisfaction of users, recommendation intention and perceived use benefit (p values <.01 ). The analysis shows that among all the user experience features, battery life, image clarity, night clarity, simplicity of archiving, and portability are the five most important features that users feel are law enforcement recorders. In Study 3, a new batch of samples (N = 182) were collected to verify the user experience model of law enforcement recorders. The confirmatory factor analysis shows that the two-factor model of "usefulness and ease of use" has a high goodness of fit, indicating that the model has a good structural validity. Further analysis shows that the two factors are significantly related to user's overall satisfaction, recommendation intention and perceived use income. The second group of users rated the most important characteristics of the experience as battery life, image clarity, night clarity, portability, and ease of filing. Taking law enforcement recorders as an example, this study constructed a user experience model of mobile police terminal equipment, based on the technology acceptance model (TAM), and extended its theory to explain and predict users' satisfaction with product experience through the usability dimension, supplementing the lack of empirical research on user experience models in the field of police equipment. The user experience model constructed in this research can be used to build a general usability standard for mobile police terminal equipment, guide the direction of product improvement and innovative design, improve the user experience level of industrial terminal equipment, and ultimately achieve the purpose of improving law enforcement efficiency, and provide support for promoting the establishment of a harmonious society. On the basis of this model, future research can increase the study of multi-police service scenarios, and verify the terminal equipment other than the law enforcement recorder, and constantly improve the model.
关键词用户体验模型 技术接受度模型 执法记录仪 因素分析 层次任务分析
学位类型继续教育硕士
语种中文
学位名称理学硕士
学位专业应用心理学
学位授予单位中国科学院大学
学位授予地点中国科学院心理研究所
文献类型学位论文
条目标识符https://ir.psych.ac.cn/handle/311026/47418
专题社会与工程心理学研究室
推荐引用方式
GB/T 7714
尚炎. 移动警务终端装备用户体验模型研究:以执法记录仪为例[D]. 中国科学院心理研究所. 中国科学院大学,2023.
条目包含的文件
文件名称/大小 文献类型 版本类型 开放类型 使用许可
尚炎-同等学力论文.pdf(3143KB)学位论文 开放获取CC BY-NC-SA请求全文
个性服务
推荐该条目
保存到收藏夹
查看访问统计
导出为Endnote文件
谷歌学术
谷歌学术中相似的文章
[尚炎]的文章
百度学术
百度学术中相似的文章
[尚炎]的文章
必应学术
必应学术中相似的文章
[尚炎]的文章
相关权益政策
暂无数据
收藏/分享
所有评论 (0)
暂无评论
 

除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。